Every fall, I find myself wandering through Costco’s bakery section, hoping to stumble upon the next seasonal gem that will satisfy my sweet tooth. This year, Costco is raising the bar with three hidden must-try bakery items that are guaranteed to fly off the shelves faster than you can say “pumpkin spice.”
With all the excitement around the new September arrivals, it’s safe to say I’m clearing space in my cart for these, too. If you’re anything like me, these fall treats will have you rushing to your nearest Costco before they’re gone. Here’s the lineup of goodies you don’t want to miss.
Mary Macleod’s All Butter Shortbread Cookies
Price: $99.99
Mary Macleod’s all-butter shortbread is what happens when you mix pure joy with rich, buttery perfection. And with this Costco-exclusive pack, you’re not just getting one jar—you’re getting two.
Yes, that’s two beautiful glass jars, each filled with 64 handcrafted cookies. You’ll get The Classic shortbread in one and the mouthwatering Chocolate Crunch shortbread in the other. That’s 128 chances to indulge in the most irresistible shortbread you’ve ever tasted.
Each jar comes with a satin ribbon, making it the perfect gift (or, you know, a treat for yourself). The Classic flavor is everything you love about shortbread—rich, buttery, and absolutely addictive.
But if you’re craving something more, the Chocolate Crunch shortbread takes it up a notch with buttery bites filled with chocolate bits and a chunky piece of chocolate on top. You can thank me later when your mouth isn’t full.
This luxurious set is perfect for the holiday season or even corporate gifting. And, honestly, if you’re not grabbing these for yourself, you’re missing out.
5 Affordable Costco Items the Middle Class Can Buy to Look ‘Effortlessly Wealthy’ This Fall
Collin Street Bakery 2 Pecan Pie Bundle
Price: $54.99
Fall isn’t complete without pecan pie, and Collin Street Bakery just made sure you’re getting two. This Pecan Pie Bundle serves up twice the goodness with two pies that will have your family and friends begging for seconds.
Each pie is packed with silky caramel-like custard, topped with crunchy pecans, and baked to absolute perfection. The flaky crust gives way to that sweet, rich filling that melts in your mouth with every bite.
What makes this bundle even better? Each pie serves 8 people, so whether you’re hosting a fall gathering or simply indulging yourself, you’ll have plenty to go around. With a diameter of 9 inches and a weight of nearly 2 pounds per pie, these are the perfect centerpiece for your fall dessert table.
And trust me, you’ll want to get these pies before they’re gone for the season.
Ferrara’s Bakery New York Cheesecake 2-pack
Price: $99.99
Last but certainly not least, we have Ferrara’s Bakery New York Cheesecakes for just $99.99. These 8-inch cheesecakes are perfectly balanced between rich cream cheese and smooth sour cream. Each cake serves 10-12 people, which means you’ll have plenty to share (or not, I won’t judge).
The cheesecakes come with a classic graham cracker crust and a flavor that’s just the right balance of creaminess without being too heavy. And if you’re wondering about freshness, don’t worry—each cake can be frozen for up to 6 months or refrigerated for up to 4 days.
What really caught my attention is Ferrara’s rich history. This family-owned business has been crafting Italian specialties in New York City since 1892, and they still bake in small batches multiple times a day to ensure freshness.
These three hidden gems will be available in Costco’s fall bakery section, but I have a feeling they won’t last long. So, if you see me power-walking through Costco with a cart full of shortbread, pecan pies, and cheesecakes… well, you won’t, lol.
